Best Italian food in Gainesville

Taste the Love in Every Slice

Order Online

4.3

(614)

Order now

(352) 333-6185

2645 Southwest 91st Street 400, Gainesville, FL

Mitchie G

The Homemade Meat Lasagna LASAGGGGGNNNNNAAAAAAA is absolutely amazing!!!

Niki Walia

I recently tried I Love NY Pizza, and it was absolutely amazing! The pizza was fresh out of the oven with a perfectly crispy crust, gooey cheese, and the most delicious toppings. Each bite was a flavor explosion, and it honestly made me feel like I was in New York. The combination of fresh ingredients and expert preparation really made this pizza stand out. I couldn’t stop eating, it was that yummy! Highly recommend to anyone looking for a truly satisfying pizza experience!

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Cheese Pizza (XL-18'')

Pizza Sauce , Cheese

Add Item

Butter Chicken Pizza (Large 16")

Authentic Indian butter chicken , special sauce, ginger , cilantro, onion, green pepper, mozzarella cheese

Add Item

Garden Salad

Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, kalamata olives, red onion with choice of dressing

Add Item

Chicken Wings

Chicken Wings Marinated served with Choice of your Flavor's

Add Item

Caesar Salad

Lettuce, Pramesaan cheese, Crutons

Add Item

Greek Salad

Spinach, Romain Lettuce, Tomato Slice, Cucumber Slice, Red Onion, Kalamata Olives, Banana Pepper, Feta Cheese

Add Item

Spring Mix Salad

Spring Mix, Tomato Slice, Red onion, Apple chips, Nuts mix , Feta cheese

Add Item

Flavorful Italian Favorites

At I Love N.Y Pizza, we’re proud to serve a variety of classic Italian dishes that will leave you craving for more. From our cheesy pepperoni pizza to our flavorful meatlover’s special, we’ve got something for everyone. If you’re craving pasta, our fettuccini Alfredo and penne a la vodka are sure to satisfy. And don’t miss out on our savory chicken Marsala – it’s a must-try!

New York Flavor, Anywhere You Are

Here’s a sneak peek of the items our customers can’t stop talking about

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.

Order Now

Convenient and Easy Ordering

We know life can be busy, and that’s why we’ve made it super simple to enjoy our food. You can easily order online for delivery or pickup. Just a few clicks, and your favorite meal is on its way! No need to stress about what to have for dinner tonight – we’ve got you covered.

I Love N.Y Pizza

Welcome to I Love N.Y Pizza, located at 2645 Southwest 91st Street 400, Gainesville, FL 32608. We’re here to bring the joy of Italian cuisine right to your table, whether you’re dining in, picking up, or enjoying our delivery service.

Come Dine With Us

Looking for a cozy spot to relax and enjoy a meal? Our restaurant offers a welcoming atmosphere where you can sit back and savor every bite. Bring your family, friends, or come solo – everyone’s welcome at I Love N.Y Pizza. We love seeing familiar faces and new guests alike. Don’t wait – treat yourself to some delicious Italian food today. Whether you’re ordering in, taking out, or dining with us, I Love N.Y Pizza is here to make your meal special.

I Love N.Y Pizza Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.

Featuring

Healthy Options

Easy Parking

Frequently asked questions

We are known for Tacos, Garlic Knots, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Chicken Tenders, American Food, Fries, Spaghetti, Wings, Calzone, Vegetarian Food, Dessert, Pizza, Caesar Salad, Stromboli, Chicken Alfredo, Lasagna, Pasta, Hawaiian Pizza, Cheese Pizza, Cheesecake, Cheese Steak, French Fries, Baked Ziti, BBQ, Chicken Wings, White Pizza, Meatballs, Salads, Burgers, Mozzarella Sticks, and Tiramisu

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Yes, we offer Takeout and Delivery

We are located in Gainesville, FL at 2645 Southwest 91st Street 400

We serve the following areas: Shannon Wood, Buckingham West, Arredondo, Kanapaha, Pine Hill Estates, Durant Estates, Beville Heights, West Hills, Gainesville, Suburban Heights, Rutledge, Daysville, Shadow Lawn Estates, Jonesville, Wimberly Estates, Wacahoota, Alachua County, Los Trancos Woods, Pinesville, Chantilly Acres.